ADI and ADC Law

Lei 9.868/99 Lei nº 9.868, de 1999 Constitucional
⇩ PDF

Provides for the procedure and judgment of the direct action of unconstitutionality and the declaratory action of constitutionality before the Federal Supreme Court.
THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC I hereby make known that the National Congress decrees and I sanction the following Law:

CHAPTER I THE DIRECT ACTION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY AND THE DECLARATORY ACTION OF CONSTITUTIONALITY

Art. 1 This Law provides for the procedure and judgment of the direct action of unconstitutionality and the declaratory action of constitutionality before the Federal Supreme Court.

CHAPTER II THE DIRECT ACTION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY

Section I Admissibility and Procedure of the Direct Action of Unconstitutionality

Art. 2 The following may file the direct action of unconstitutionality: (See Article 103 of the Federal Constitution)
I - the President of the Republic;
II - the Board of the Federal Senate;
III - the Board of the Chamber of Deputies;
IV - the Board of a Legislative Assembly or the Board of the Legislative Chamber of the Federal District;
V - the Governor of a State or the Governor of the Federal District;
VI - the Prosecutor General of the Republic;
VII - the Federal Council of the Order of Attorneys of Brazil;
VIII - a political party with representation in the National Congress;
IX - a labor union confederation or a national-level professional association.
Sole paragraph. (VETOED)
Art. 3 The petition shall state:
I - the provision of the law or normative act being challenged and the legal grounds for the request with respect to each challenge;
II - the request, with its specifications.
Sole paragraph. The initial petition, accompanied by a power of attorney when signed by an attorney, shall be filed in two copies and shall contain copies of the law or normative act being challenged and of the documents necessary to substantiate the challenge.
Art. 4 The rapporteur shall summarily dismiss an initial petition that is inept, unsubstantiated, or manifestly unfounded.
Sole paragraph. An interlocutory appeal lies from the decision dismissing the initial petition.
Art. 5 Once the direct action has been filed, withdrawal shall not be permitted.
Sole paragraph. (VETOED)
Art. 6 The rapporteur shall request information from the bodies or authorities from which the challenged law or normative act originated.
Sole paragraph. The information shall be provided within thirty days, counted from receipt of the request.
Art. 7 Intervention by third parties shall not be permitted in the proceedings of a direct action of unconstitutionality.
§ 1 (VETOED)
§ 2 The rapporteur, considering the relevance of the matter and the representativeness of the applicants, may, by an order not subject to appeal, admit the statement of other bodies or entities, within the period set forth in the preceding paragraph.
Art. 8 Upon expiration of the period for the information, the Attorney General of the Union and the Prosecutor General of the Republic shall be heard in succession, and each shall submit a statement within fifteen days.
Art. 9 Upon expiration of the periods set forth in the preceding article, the rapporteur shall issue the report, with a copy to all Justices, and shall request a date for judgment.
§ 1 If it is necessary to clarify a matter or a factual circumstance, or if the information in the record is clearly insufficient, the rapporteur may request additional information, appoint an expert or a committee of experts to issue an opinion on the question, or set a date to hear, at a public hearing, testimony from persons with experience and authority in the matter.
§ 2 The rapporteur may also request information from the Superior Courts, the federal Courts, and the state Courts about the application of the challenged rule within their jurisdictions.
§ 3 The information, expert examinations, and hearings referred to in the preceding paragraphs shall be completed within thirty days, counted from the rapporteur's request.

Section II Precautionary Measures in the Direct Action of Unconstitutionality

Art. 10. Except during the recess period, the precautionary measure in the direct action shall be granted by decision of the absolute majority of the members of the Court, subject to the provisions of Art. 22, after hearing the bodies or authorities from which the challenged law or normative act originated, which shall respond within five days.
§ 1 If the rapporteur deems it indispensable, the rapporteur shall hear the Attorney General of the Union and the Prosecutor General of the Republic within three days.
§ 2 In the judgment of the request for a precautionary measure, oral argument shall be permitted to the legal representatives of the petitioner and of the authorities or bodies responsible for issuing the act, as provided in the Rules of the Court.
§ 3 In cases of exceptional urgency, the Court may grant the precautionary measure without hearing the bodies or authorities from which the challenged law or normative act originated.
Art. 11. Once the precautionary measure has been granted, the Federal Supreme Court shall publish the operative part of the decision in a special section of the Official Gazette of the Union and of the Justice Gazette of the Union within ten days, and shall request information from the authority from which the act originated, observing, as applicable, the procedure established in Section I of this Chapter.
§ 1 The precautionary measure, which has effect against all, shall be granted with ex nunc effect, unless the Court determines that it should be granted retroactive effect.
§ 2 The granting of the precautionary measure makes the prior legislation, if any, applicable again, unless expressly provided otherwise.
Art. 12. If a precautionary measure is requested, the rapporteur, in view of the relevance of the matter and its special significance for the social order and legal certainty, may, after the information has been provided within ten days and the Attorney General of the Union and the Prosecutor General of the Republic have submitted their statements in succession within five days, submit the case directly to the Court, which may then finally decide the action. (See ADO No. 26)

Chapter II-A (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).

The Direct Action of Unconstitutionality by Omission

Section I — Admissibility and Procedure of the Direct Action of Unconstitutionality by

Art. 12-A. Those who have standing to file the direct action of unconstitutionality and the declaratory action of constitutionality may file the direct action of unconstitutionality by omission. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Art. 12-B. The petition shall state: (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
I - the total or partial unconstitutional omission regarding compliance with a constitutional duty to legislate or regarding the adoption of a measure of an administrative nature; (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
II - the request, with its specifications. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Sole paragraph. The initial petition, accompanied by a power of attorney, if applicable, shall be filed in 2 (two) copies and shall contain copies of the documents necessary to substantiate the allegation of omission. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Art. 12-C. The rapporteur shall summarily dismiss an initial petition that is inept, unsubstantiated, or manifestly unfounded. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Sole paragraph. An interlocutory appeal lies from the decision dismissing the initial petition. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Art. 12-D. Once the direct action of unconstitutionality by omission has been filed, withdrawal shall not be permitted. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Art. 12-E. The provisions of Section I of Chapter II of this Law apply, as applicable, to the procedure of the direct action of unconstitutionality by omission. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 1 The other holders of standing referred to in Art. 2 of this Law may submit written statements on the subject matter of the action and request the filing of documents deemed useful for examining the matter, within the period for the information, and may also submit memorials. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 2 The rapporteur may request a statement from the Attorney General of the Union, which shall be submitted within 15 (fifteen) days. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 3 In actions in which the Prosecutor General of the Republic is not the plaintiff, the Prosecutor General shall have access to the case file for 15 (fifteen) days after the period for the information has expired. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).

Section II — Precautionary Measures in the Direct Action of Unconstitutionality by Omission

Art. 12-F. In cases of exceptional urgency and relevance of the matter, the Court, by decision of the absolute majority of its members, subject to the provisions of Art. 22, may grant a precautionary measure, after hearing the bodies or authorities responsible for the unconstitutional omission, which shall respond within 5 (five) days. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 1 In the case of partial omission, the precautionary measure may consist of suspending the application of the challenged law or normative act, as well as suspending judicial proceedings or administrative procedures, or any other measure to be determined by the Court. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 2 If the rapporteur deems it indispensable, the rapporteur shall hear the Prosecutor General of the Republic within 3 (three) days. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 3 In the judgment of the request for a precautionary measure, oral argument shall be permitted to the legal representatives of the petitioner and of the authorities or bodies responsible for the unconstitutional omission, as provided in the Rules of the Court. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
Art. 12-G. Once the precautionary measure has been granted, the Federal Supreme Court shall publish the operative part of the decision in a special section of the Official Gazette of the Union and of the Justice Gazette of the Union within 10 (ten) days, and shall request information from the authority or body responsible for the unconstitutional omission, observing, as applicable, the procedure established in Section I of Chapter II of this Law. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).

Section III — The Decision in the Direct Action of Unconstitutionality by Omission

Art. 12-H. Once unconstitutionality by omission has been declared, in compliance with the provisions of Art. 22, notice shall be given to the competent Branch of Government to adopt the necessary measures. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 1 In the case of an omission attributable to an administrative body, the measures shall be adopted within 30 (thirty) days, or within a reasonable period to be set exceptionally by the Court, in view of the specific circumstances of the case and the public interest involved. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).
§ 2 The provisions of Chapter IV of this Law apply, as applicable, to the decision in the direct action of unconstitutionality by omission. (Included by Law 12.063 of 2009).

CHAPTER III THE DECLARATORY ACTION OF CONSTITUTIONALITY

Section I Admissibility and Procedure of the Declaratory Action of Constitutionality

Art. 13. The following may file the declaratory action of constitutionality of a federal law or normative act: (See Article 103 of the Federal Constitution)
I - the President of the Republic;
II - the Board of the Chamber of Deputies;
III - the Board of the Federal Senate;
IV - the Prosecutor General of the Republic.
Art. 14. The initial petition shall state:
I - the provision of the law or normative act in question and the legal grounds for the request;
II - the request, with its specifications;
III - the existence of a relevant judicial controversy regarding the application of the provision that is the subject of the declaratory action.
Sole paragraph. The initial petition, accompanied by a power of attorney when signed by an attorney, shall be filed in two copies and shall contain copies of the normative act in question and of the documents necessary to substantiate the request for a declaration of constitutionality.
Art. 15. The rapporteur shall summarily dismiss an initial petition that is inept, unsubstantiated, or manifestly unfounded.
Sole paragraph. An interlocutory appeal lies from the decision dismissing the initial petition.
Art. 16. Once the declaratory action has been filed, withdrawal shall not be permitted.
Art. 17. (VETOED)
Art. 18. Intervention by third parties shall not be permitted in the proceedings of a declaratory action of constitutionality.
§ 1 (VETOED)
§ 2 (VETOED)
Art. 19. Once the period set in the preceding article has elapsed, the case file shall be opened to the Attorney General of the Republic, who shall issue an opinion within fifteen days.
Art. 20. Once the period set in the preceding article has expired, the rapporteur shall prepare the report, with a copy to all Justices, and shall request a date for judgment.
§ 1 Where it is necessary to clarify a matter or a factual circumstance, or where the information in the case file is clearly insufficient, the rapporteur may request additional information, appoint an expert or a commission of experts to issue an opinion on the issue, or set a date for a public hearing to hear testimony from persons with experience and authority in the matter.
§ 2 The rapporteur may also request information from the Superior Courts, the federal Courts, and the state Courts on the application of the challenged norm within their jurisdiction.
§ 3 The information, expert opinions, and hearings referred to in the preceding paragraphs shall be completed within thirty days, counted from the rapporteur's request.

SECTION II On Preliminary Injunctions in the Declaratory Action of Constitutionality

Art. 21. The Federal Supreme Court, by decision of the absolute majority of its members, may grant a request for a preliminary injunction in the declaratory action of constitutionality, consisting of an order that judges and Courts suspend the judgment of cases involving the application of the law or normative act that is the subject of the action until its final judgment.
Sole paragraph. If the preliminary injunction is granted, the Federal Supreme Court shall publish the operative part of the decision in a special section of the Diário Oficial da União within ten days, and the Court shall judge the action within one hundred eighty days, under penalty of the injunction losing its effectiveness.

CHAPTER IV ON THE DECISION IN THE DIRECT ACTION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY AND IN THE DECLARATORY ACTION OF CONSTITUTIONALITY

Art. 22. The decision on the constitutionality or unconstitutionality of the law or normative act shall be made only if at least eight Justices are present at the session.
Art. 23. Once judgment is rendered, the constitutionality or unconstitutionality of the challenged provision or norm shall be proclaimed if at least six Justices have voted one way or the other, whether the case is a direct action of unconstitutionality or a declaratory action of constitutionality.
Sole paragraph. If the majority required to declare constitutionality or unconstitutionality is not reached, and the number of absent Justices could affect the outcome, the judgment shall be suspended to await the attendance of the absent Justices, until the number required to render a decision one way or the other is reached.
Art. 24. If constitutionality is proclaimed, the direct action shall be dismissed, or any declaratory action shall be upheld; and if unconstitutionality is proclaimed, the direct action shall be upheld, or any declaratory action shall be dismissed.
Art. 25. Once the action is judged, notice shall be given to the authority or body responsible for issuing the act.
Art. 26. The decision that declares the constitutionality or unconstitutionality of a law or normative act in a direct action or in a declaratory action is not subject to appeal, except for motions for clarification, and likewise may not be the subject of a rescissory action.
Art. 27. When declaring the unconstitutionality of a law or normative act, and in view of reasons of legal certainty or exceptional social interest, the Federal Supreme Court, by a majority of two thirds of its members, may restrict the effects of that declaration or decide that it takes effect only once the decision becomes final and unappealable or at another time to be set.
Art. 28. Within ten days after the decision becomes final and unappealable, the Federal Supreme Court shall publish the operative part of the judgment in a special section of the Diário da Justiça and the Diário Oficial da União.
Sole paragraph. The declaration of constitutionality or unconstitutionality, including interpretation in conformity with the Constitution and partial declaration of unconstitutionality without reduction of text, has effect against everyone and binding effect on the bodies of the Judicial Branch and on the federal, state, and municipal Public Administration.

CHAPTER V ON GENERAL AND FINAL PROVISIONS

Art. 29. Art. 482 of the Code of Civil Procedure is supplemented with the following paragraphs:
"Art. 482............................................................................
§ 1 The Public Prosecution Service and the legal entities of public law responsible for issuing the challenged act, if they so request, may submit statements in the incident of unconstitutionality, subject to the periods and conditions set in the Internal Rules of the Court.
§ 2 The holders of the right to bring an action referred to in art. 103 of the Constitution may submit written statements on the constitutional question under review by the special panel or by the Full Court, within the period set in the Rules. They are guaranteed the right to submit briefs or to request the attachment of documents.
§ 3 Considering the relevance of the matter and the representativeness of the petitioners, the rapporteur may admit, by an order not subject to appeal, statements from other bodies or entities."
Art. 30. Art. 8 of Law 8.185, of May 14, 1991, is supplemented with the following provisions:
"Art. 8.............................................................................
I -.....................................................................................
........................................................................................
n) the direct action of unconstitutionality of a law or normative act of the Federal District in light of its Organic Law;
.......................................................................................
§ 3 The following have standing to bring the direct action of unconstitutionality:
I - the Governor of the Federal District;
II - the Board of the Legislative Chamber;
III - the Attorney General of Justice;
IV - the Brazilian Bar Association, Federal District section;
V - union or class entities operating in the Federal District, provided they demonstrate that the claim they assert bears a direct relationship of pertinence to their institutional objectives;
VI - political parties with representation in the Legislative Chamber.
§ 4 The following provisions apply to the processing and judgment of the direct action of unconstitutionality before the Court of Justice of the Federal District and Territories:
I - the Attorney General of Justice shall always be heard in direct actions of constitutionality or unconstitutionality;
II - if unconstitutionality by omission is declared for failure to adopt a measure to give effect to a norm of the Organic Law of the Federal District, the decision shall be communicated to the competent Branch for adoption of the necessary measures and, in the case of an administrative body, for it to do so within thirty days;
III - the Court of Justice may declare the unconstitutionality of a law or normative act of the Federal District, or suspend its effectiveness in a preliminary injunction decision, only by the vote of the absolute majority of its members or of its special panel.
§ 5 The rules on the processing and judgment of the direct action of unconstitutionality before the Federal Supreme Court apply, as applicable, to the processing and judgment of the direct action of unconstitutionality of a law or normative act of the Federal District in light of its Organic Law."
Art. 31. This Law takes effect on the date of its publication.
Brasília, November 10, 1999; 178th year of Independence and 111th of the Republic.
FERNANDO HENRIQUE CARDOSO José Carlos Dias
This text does not replace the text published in the DOU of 11.11.1999
*

No blog