“I had no way of going back to work” — Dona Marlene’s benefit was reinstated

Dona Marlene received a letter from the INSS (Brazil’s National Social Security Institute) saying she was fit to work. The problem is that her body said exactly the opposite, and so did her medical reports.
The problem
Her disability benefit was terminated overnight, after a quick medical examination that ignored her health condition. With no benefit and no ability to work, Dona Marlene was left with nothing to stand on.
What we did
We organized all of the medical evidence, including reports, test results and clinical statements, and showed in court that her disability had never gone away. We showed that the termination was improper from the very first day.
Understanding disability benefits
Stories like Dona Marlene’s happen again and again because many people do not know exactly what right is at stake when poor health keeps them from working. It is worth explaining, in general terms, the legal ground behind this kind of case.
Disability benefits are provided for in Law 8.213/1991, which structures Brazil’s Social Security system (Previdência Social). When a person is temporarily unable to perform their usual activity, the law provides for the temporary disability benefit (auxílio por incapacidade temporária), formerly known as auxílio-doença. When the disability is permanent and the insured person cannot be retrained for another job, the permanent disability retirement benefit (aposentadoria por incapacidade permanente) comes into play, formerly called aposentadoria por invalidez. In both cases, the logic is the same: as long as a person cannot work for health reasons, Social Security should support them financially.
Why the INSS terminates benefits
As a rule, a disability benefit is not permanent. The law allows the INSS to schedule review examinations to check whether the disability persists. This is where problems arise. Many terminations follow brief examinations in which the examiner did not have time to look carefully at the clinical history, or did not give proper weight to the reports of the doctor who has treated the patient for years. The result is a decision that declares the person fit to work when, in practice, they are still ill.
A hasty termination does not erase an illness. Whatever was disabling the person before the examination is still there the next day, and that is what the medical evidence needs to show.
The evidence that tends to be decisive
In disability disputes, the case is won or lost on the quality of the medical evidence. It is not enough to say that an illness exists. You have to show, in an organized way, that the condition prevents you from working and that it already existed when the benefit was cut off. Several kinds of evidence tend to carry significant weight in these cases:
- Reports from your treating physician: the professional who follows the patient throughout treatment has a continuous view of the condition, something a examination lasting a few minutes can rarely match. Detailed reports, with a diagnosis, progression and functional limitations, tend to carry a lot of weight.
- Supporting tests: imaging, lab work and other objective tests help prove that the health condition exists and how serious it is.
- Dated reports and prescriptions: dated documents help build a timeline of the illness and show that the disability was already present before the termination.
- History of leaves and treatments: continuing treatment reinforces that the health problem did not disappear overnight.
Organizing these documents into a clear narrative is what allows the judge to see what a single examination missed. This work of gathering and presenting the evidence was at the heart of Dona Marlene’s case.
The path from the INSS to the courts
In general, when an insured person disagrees with an INSS decision, there are a few possible paths, both administrative and judicial.
The administrative path
Even before a termination takes effect, someone who feels they still cannot work can request an extension of the benefit within the deadline, known as a pedido de prorrogação (extension request). If the benefit has already been denied or terminated, you can file an administrative appeal with the Social Security Appeals Council, which reviews the decision. This path has the advantage of not requiring a lawsuit, but it does not always overturn poorly conducted examinations.
The judicial path
When the administrative route does not solve the problem, the insured person can take the matter to the Federal Courts (Justiça Federal), which have jurisdiction over cases against the INSS. In a lawsuit, the court ordinarily appoints an examiner to conduct a medical examination, a professional who represents neither the insured person nor the INSS. This expert report, together with the medical evidence the party submits, forms the basis for the decision. When the court finds that the disability existed and that the termination was improper, it can order the benefit reinstated and the overdue payments made, counted from the date the benefit was cut off. That is the conclusion reached in the case described here.
What this could mean for you
Every case is unique, and no past result guarantees the same outcome for anyone else. Still, experience shows a few points worth keeping in mind if your benefit is terminated.
A denial or termination by the INSS is not, in itself, the final word. Administrative decisions can be reviewed, both within the INSS itself and before the courts. If your health condition still keeps you from working, that reality can be shown through the right medical evidence.
Keeping and organizing your documents makes a difference. Reports, test results, prescriptions and statements, with dates, help build the timeline of the illness. The more complete and consistent this set of documents is, the clearer it becomes that the disability did not go away.
It is also important to watch the deadlines. Extension requests, administrative appeals and lawsuits each have their own time windows, and acting within the right time frame usually expands your options for defending your right.
Finally, remember that no one has to go down this path alone. Understanding which benefit is at stake, gathering the right evidence and choosing the proper route, administrative or judicial, are steps that legal guidance can help organize, always in light of the particulars of each situation.
A denial from the INSS is not the end of the road. With the right evidence, a right can be recovered.