Expert Fees and the Initial Petition in Disability Benefit Cases

Lei 14.331/22 Lei nº 14.331, de 2022 Previdenciário
⇩ PDF

Amends Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019, and Law 8.213 of July 24, 1991, to provide for the payment of expert fees and for the requirements of the initial petition in litigation and precautionary measures concerning welfare assistance benefits and social security disability benefits; and repeals a provision of Law 8.620 of January 5, 1993.
THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC I hereby make known that the National Congress decrees and I sanction the following Law:
Art. 1 This Law amends Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019, and Law 8.213 of July 24, 1991, to provide for the payment of expert fees in actions that address the granting of welfare assistance benefits to persons with disabilities or social security disability benefits, and for the requirements of the initial petition in litigation and precautionary measures concerning disability benefits.
Art. 2 Art. 1 of Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019, is hereby amended to read as follows:
"Art. 1 The burden of the costs relating to the payment of expert fees for court-ordered expert examinations conducted in actions in which the Instituto Nacional do Seguro Social (INSS) is a party and which address the granting of welfare assistance benefits to persons with disabilities or social security benefits resulting from work incapacity shall fall on the losing party, pursuant to civil procedure legislation, in particular § 3 of Art. 98 of Law 13.105 of March 16, 2015 (Code of Civil Procedure).
...................................................................................................................................................
§ 3 (Repealed).
§ 4 The payment of expert fees is limited to 1 (one) medical expert examination per court case, and, exceptionally, if so determined by higher instances of the Judiciary, another expert examination may be conducted.
§ 5 Beginning in 2022, in the actions referred to in the main provision of this article, the burden of advancing the cost of the expert examination is reversed, and the defendant, regardless of the rite or procedure adopted, shall advance the payment of the amount set for conducting the expert examination, except in the case provided for in § 6 of this article.
§ 6 Plaintiffs in lawsuits relating to welfare assistance benefits to persons with disabilities or to social security benefits resulting from work incapacity, as provided for in the main provision of this article, who demonstrably have sufficient means to bear the costs of advancing the expenses relating to court-ordered medical expert examinations, shall advance the costs of the expenses relating to the payment of expert fees.
§ 7 The burden of advancing the payment of the expert examination, as provided for in § 5 of this article, shall fall on the federal Executive Branch and shall be processed as follows:
I – in actions within the jurisdiction of the Federal Courts, including those that proceed in the State Courts by delegation of jurisdiction, the budget appropriations for the payment of expert fees shall be decentralized by the central body of the Federal Financial Administration System to the Council of Federal Justice, which shall be responsible for decentralizing them to the Regional Federal Courts, which shall transfer the amounts to the court-appointed experts after they have performed their duty, regardless of the outcome or duration of the action, and the use of these funds for other purposes is prohibited;
II – in work accident actions, within the jurisdiction of the State Courts, the expert fees shall be advanced by the INSS." (NR)
Art. 3 Law 8.213 of July 24, 1991, is hereby supplemented with the following Arts. 129-A and 135-A:
"Art. 129-A. Litigation and precautionary measures concerning the disability benefits addressed in this Law, including those relating to work accidents, shall observe the following:
I – when the basis of the action is the challenge of an act performed by the federal medical expert service, the initial petition must contain, in addition to the requirements provided for in Art. 319 of Law 13.105 of March 16, 2015 (Code of Civil Procedure):
a) a clear description of the illness and the limitations it imposes;
b) an indication of the activity for which the plaintiff claims to be incapacitated;
c) possible inconsistencies in the medical expert assessment under challenge; and
d) a statement as to the existence of a prior lawsuit with the subject matter addressed in this article, explaining the reasons why it is understood that there is no lis pendens or res judicata, when applicable;
II – in order to comply with Art. 320 of Law 13.105 of March 16, 2015 (Code of Civil Procedure), the initial petition, regardless of the rite or procedure adopted, must be accompanied by the plaintiff with the following documents:
a) proof of denial of the benefit or of its non-extension, when applicable, by the public administration;
b) proof of the occurrence of the accident of any nature or of the work accident, whenever an accident is identified as the cause of the incapacity;
c) any medical documentation available relating to the illness alleged as the cause of the incapacity contested in the administrative proceeding.
§ 1 When the court orders a medical expert examination to be conducted by a court-appointed expert, the expert must, in case of disagreement with the conclusions of the administrative report, indicate in the expert's report, with supporting reasons, the technical and scientific grounds that support the disagreement, especially with regard to proof of the incapacity, its starting date and its correlation with the work activity of the person being examined.
§ 2 When the conclusion of the medical expert examination conducted by an expert appointed by the court upholds the result of the decision issued by the expert examination conducted in the administrative proceeding, the court may, after hearing the plaintiff, dismiss the claim.
§ 3 If the dispute involves points other than those requiring a medical expert examination, subject to § 1 of this article, the court shall proceed with the case, with service of process on the defendant."
"Art. 135-A. For an insured person enrolled in Social Security up to July 1994, in calculating the benefit salary of retirement pensions, except the permanent disability retirement pension, the divisor considered in calculating the average of the contribution salaries may not be less than 108 (one hundred eight) months."
Art. 4 The application of the provisions of Art. 2 of this Law, which amends Art. 1 of Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019, is conditional upon express physical and financial authorization in the annual budget law for the resulting expenses.
Art. 5 Expert examinations conducted between September 20, 2021, and the date of publication of this Law shall be paid in accordance with §§ 5 and 7 of Art. 1 of Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019.
Art. 6 The following provisions are hereby repealed:
I - § 2 of Art. 8 of Law 8.620 of January 5, 1993; and
II - § 3 of Art. 1 of Law 13.876 of September 20, 2019.
Art. 7 This Law enters into force on the date of its publication.
Brasília, May 4, 2022; 201st year of Independence and 134th year of the Republic.
JAIR MESSIAS BOLSONARO
José Carlos Oliveira
*

No blog